Monday, 21 February 2011

The Grand Strategy for the Middle East

Last week I blogged about Niall Ferguson’s Newsweek cover story attacking President Obama’s lack of a “grand strategy” for the Middle East. I thought he made some good points, although he failed to mention the elephant in the room - the Israel Lobby.

Matt Duss has done an excellent job deconstructing Ferguson’s argument Niall Ferguson’s Phoned-In Obama Bashing
Others have already criticized  but I want to specifically address Ferguson’s suggestion that Obama has “just missed — again — …the revolutionary wave of Middle Eastern democracy“:
It seems to have become a bit of conservative campfire folklore that, by failing to say just the right things at just the right times in June 2009, President Obama somehow aborted the second Iranian revolution. Understand, the next person to describe a plausible scenario in which Obama could have actually effected a different outcome than the one that occurred in June 2009 will be the first. Ferguson accuses Obama of doing “nothing” — which is untrue — but what is the “something” that President Obama, or any U.S. president, could have done to prevent “the thugs of the Islamic Republic” from “ruthlessly crushing the demonstrations”? Ferguson doesn’t say. Because, of course, he doesn’t know.
Read more here

And his "Letter from Herzliya"  was published earlier this week in "The Nation" magazine online.